Saturday, April 29, 2017
Saturday, April 15, 2017
MONTESSORI CIRCLE
This book is an earnest attempt to understand the Montessori
way of education and help others who want to do so. It also
discusses the relevance of the methodology to the current
scenario and how it could be a solution to a number of
education-related issues. I am open enough to say in advance
that my approach to Montessori is not critical, except with
respect to how some people treat it. Four decades ago, I started
my career as a tutor for a group of young people who had
dropped out of school and then continued their education in
private. It was an opening for me to materialize my passionate
dream of becoming a teacher. As time went by, I started my
school organization. However, instead of being a satisfied
teacher to many outstanding students, several unresolved
issues that I had to face as a teacher or as the school manager
haunted me. I knew that this was not my only concern, but
every educator involved must face it although the intensity
varies. The general conclusion that something is wrong with
the system was unacceptable to me. And so, I continued my
search for a solution for the set of issues that I thought most
important. If I sum them up, they are
1. Generally, pupils are not interested in school, although
school is an inseparable part of their life. They look happy
when they're not in school.
2. School activities are not student-centred, and so a variety of
other concerns conflict and collide in school-events to spoil
the real purpose.
3. The life of a student seems unbearable when you look at the
teaching-learning process from the perspective of the
students.
5
4. A slow learner remains a backbencher throughout his
education, although his teachers have identified him in his
kindergarten level.
5. The lessons they learn in schools and universities are not
meant to solve real-life problems.
I read as many books as possible, attended seminars and had
discussions with like-minded people, but I did not find a
satisfactory solution. I thought I was looking for something
unattainable.
The reading of ‘The discovery of the child’ and ‘The
Absorbent mind’, both written by Dr Maria Montessori was
an eye-opener to me. Eventually, I felt I could reach the
pedagogical philosophy that I was searching for. The
philosophy suggested a fairly simple relief for all the issues
that I took to be extremely complicated. How simple was that?
I was sceptical for a while to the idea of whether it would
work.
I saw that it was supported and promoted by renowned
scientists such as Thomas Edison and Alexander Graham Bell,
psychologists such as Sigmund Freud and Jean Piaget, the
Nobel laureate as Rabindranath Tagore. The critic was also
one of the leading figures of the time, William H Kilpatrick, a
renowned student of Professor John Dewey, Dr Montessori's
contemporary educational philosopher. Anyway, I decided to
see it myself, took an online course, got a diploma, brought
Montessori materials, and started the 'Montessori House of
Children'.
All that is mentioned in this book is based on my learning,
understanding and experience on the subject, Montessori. I
tried to express the things I wanted to say in a coherent way,
but the breadth of the subject prevented me from cataloguing
them in perfect order. I apologize if that breaks legibility. But
it is useful in a way that a reader may take little by little, which
he or she thinks convenient. As such, it would require no
sophistication from the reader's side. Take the topic as the title
6
indicates and you can continue without responsibility or
burden.
I split my opening comment into two questions.
Why is this book? Who is this book aimed at? First, the
Montessori method is scientific, just and student-centred, but
not the government-sponsored due to a myriad of reasons.
Therefore, brief handbooks are not available. It took me two
years and long reading sessions to develop a sense of
Montessori as a teaching methodology. Books weren't
available either, thanks to online platforms, but now it's
handy. Then I thought a book as a gateway that describes the
philosophy and practice of the method would be useful for one
who wants to get a synoptic awareness. The Montessori
method really deserves promotion. Many people think the
same, but do not have the know-how to begin or run a
'Montessori House of Children'. The limited number of
training-facility in this country prevents the teachers from
getting trained. This book may work as a guide for them too.
Second, I think that a debate about the relevance of the subject
is the need for time, especially when a sort of stagnation has
crept into the system. You may think of this book as an
initiative in this regard.
For a beginner, it may be useful to know certain uses or
phrases related to the Montessori method. Among them, the
first is the House of Children. This is a well-planned and
prepared environment where a child's education begins within
the Montessori system. Children from three to six years are
admitted for primary education. There will be no grading or
division of rank between them. Then comes "Montessori
equipment". These are educational materials designed to
educate children (most of which are designed by Dr Maria
Montessori). ‘Montessori teacher' is a qualified teacher of the
Montessori method. The general use of the term “teacher” in
this book refers to “Montessori teacher”. The didactic aids are
7
categorized into some sections according to the type of work.
They are known as
1. Sensorial materials
2. Practical life materials
3. Mathematical materials
4. Language materials
5. Geography and Biology materials
6. Art and music materials...
Throughout this book, the pronoun 'he' is used for a child. It's
not because of any gender bias, but 'it' seems to be a little
inanimate for a child and 'she' is reserved for mother nature
and teacher. One more thing, there is a confusion of the usage
of ‘Montessori’ as the same is used for the method and its
inventor. Here, in this book, simple notation of Montessori
refers the method and Dr Montessori denotes the founder Dr
Maria Montessori.
I, broadly and for convenience, assimilated twelve principles
of Montessori philosophy to pen this book.
Follow the child. Nature has encrypted the laws of
development and programmed the child, and the child
intrinsically knows how to decode it and use it for his growth.
And only the child possesses the key to open it. Therefore, the
primary duty of adults and educators, particularly is to follow
the child. Any sort of domination, persuasion or imposition
will harm the child’s growth both mentally and physically.
Cognition through movement. The capacity for voluntary
movement is the very quality of the human being as a species
has played a crucial role in its development. And this is the
secret of his being supreme among other creatures. This acted
as the core agent for the development of his cognitive powers.
Movements under infinite forms therefore continue to be the
basis of child development.
Freedom to select. Contrary to what we think, a child does not
have to be under the command of someone. That means that
8
the choice of action should be reserved for the child rather
than his or her guardian. Freedom of choice is nothing else but
his birthright. So, a child can have his choice to do or not do
something.
Peer learning and teaching. Clustering of children, if
necessary, should be based on developmental stages, not age
or size. This enables them to maintain social relations that are
essential to their development. This way of working together
also provides many opportunities for learning and teaching
among peers. In a learning environment, such as Montessori,
this is inevitable for better and natural learning.
Development from within. A child is not an excellent piece of
stone to be chiselled out a beautiful statue by an eminent
sculptor, but an animate integrated being to develop fully.
Thus, the most minute development that takes place in a child
should be an intrinsic affair.
Exclusion of awards and punishment. A reward, as well as a
punishment, is restricted, as both are harmful to child
development. All sorts of impositions, regardless of the
objectives, do more damage than help. Refusing to do
something does not mean that he completely rejected it, just
that he does not want to do it at that time. Likewise, his
initiative is an indication of his interest. Subverting the plan
by offering a reward or punishment has only negative
consequences.
Self-education. Every child can explore this world, understand
it, and find his or her place and cosmic duty. Besides, his
spontaneity and intuition should be his credible source of
education. Thus, 'let him learn' is the best attitude of guardians
and teachers towards a child. It does not mean leaving the
child to his fate, but to provide him with the appropriate
environment that meets his needs.
Learn context from material to abstraction. Education is not a
matter of lecturing, listening, reading, and writing, but
understanding one’s world and oneself. Abstraction of ideas
9
becomes the core objective. Verbal discourse does not lead
much to this, but experiential activities are the only
educational process. In Montessori, we always go from
concreteness to abstraction as a learning process.
Fairy-tale free. A child of young age is not capable to imagine
something as he engages with only real things, interacts with
only reality. So, unreal, like fairy tale characters, epic heroes
and even the Gods of religions, will harm his rational thinking
process.
Orderliness, physical and psychical. Nature is so because it's
in perfect order. So, the order is the foremost thing to be
achieved in a place of education. It doesn't mean discipline
imposed by any other agencies, but keeping natural
orderliness.
Sensitive periods. A sensitive period is a period that causes a
significant change within the life cycle of a living being.
Nature makes its subjects able to achieve something very
important in that particular time frame. For example, a child
acquires and speaks a language before he is three years old.
Each of his accomplishments is easy for him as he is
influenced by a sensitive period. If the language acquisition
does not take place in the period, the child may not speak, as
this development is supposed to happen in the sensitive
period.
Child psychology. Child psychology was a set of theories
based on speculations and assumptions of adults'
conveniences and conventions before Dr Montessori.
However, she came across something new and unprecedented
about a child and his mind. Her educational system is also
built on the psychology of the child, the absorbing mind.
To those who may read this book, unlike other topics, you
cannot read if you position yourself firmly in relation to your
convictions especially when you are new to Montessori. In
case you are a stringent Montessorian too, you may disagree
with some of the ideas that I put forward. My point: here, we
10
need a transition from the philosophical mode to the scientific
approach that can lead us to reality prevails. When we depend
philosophy alone, I think, we are sometimes moving away
from reality. For example, educational philosophies are
concerned, they are aimed at teachers and schools but they are
not decision-makers, that the State really determines curricula
and not educators and institutions. Then how do we move then
ignoring that factor?
Epistemology may be amalgams of philosophies but, in my
view, should not stand for eternal subtlety. Subtlety does not
exist in ideas, but the distant quality of matter is the one true
being.
I think any debate on education should aim for social change,
not just a philosophical exercise.
So, let's get into this book without prejudice, without
ideological commitment and without big expectations.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
